Ship Thumbprint Cookies Anywhere

Send Thumbprint Cookies as gifts, bring a batch to any party, treat your entire office staff, or simply order for yourself!

Order Now

Want to Order Thumbprint Cookies Today?

Our Thumbprint Cookies are made from a special type of shortbread. These were once made with the baker’s thumb making a small indentation in the center. Today, each cookie is evenly baked with a buttery, crumbly texture and a hint of vanilla. They’re topped with a drop of sugary-sweet and colorful icing. They are perfect for a sweet snack or as a party treat.

Why Order Thumbprint Cookies from The Village Bake Shop?

There are plenty of places to buy Thumbprint Cookies and other delicious treats online. So, what sets The Village Bake Shop apart from the competition? Here are a few reasons why our cookies are the best choice for every occasion:

Quality Ingredients

We use only the freshest and highest-quality ingredients in our cookies, like premium butter and the finest sugar. We never use preservatives or other additives, so you can feel good about eating a few sweets.

Bright Icing, Tastes Good

We decorate each Thumbprint Cookie with a dollop of vividly sweet colored icing. From Tennessee Orange to American Red and soft pink too, our cookies are anything but ordinary and will make you look great at any event!

Small-Batch Baking

The Village Bake Shop is a family-owned and operated bakery that sources many ingredients from local producers. Our bakers are experienced professionals who take pride in their work and are passionate about creating delicious baked treats.

Convenient Shipping

You can easily order our cookies and have them shipped directly to your doorstep. We offer nationwide shipping via USPS and they typically reach their destination in 2-4 days.

Convenient Shipping

At the Village Bake Shop, we're committed to providing the best possible customer service. Whether you have a question about our cookies or need help placing an order, our team is always here to help. Call us at 423-476-5179.

The most delicious Thumbprint cookies

Collapsible content

How are the Thumbprint Cookies from the Village Bake Shop packaged for shipping?

Thumbprint Cookies from the Village Bake Shop are carefully packaged to ensure that they arrive at your door in perfect condition. Each batch of Thumbprint Cookies are placed in a sturdy box with padding to prevent them from getting crushed or broken during shipping. The cookies themselves are packed in a plastic food-safe container to keep fresh. Also, we offer priority shipping options for those who need cookies quicker!

What is the process for ordering Thumbprint Cookies online from the Village Bake Shop?

Ordering Thumbprint Cookies online from the Village Bake Shop is a simple and straightforward process. First, simply browse our selection of Thumbprint Cookies. Once you have chosen your desired colors and quantities, add them to your cart and proceed to checkout. You will need to provide your shipping address along with your secure payment information.

What makes Thumbprint Cookies from the Village Bake Shop better than those from other bakeries?

There are many great reasons to order Thumbprint Cookies online from Village Bake Shop. We use fresh ingredients, include no preservatives, and have a wide selection of customizable color combinations. Our cookies are freshly baked to order, affordable, and each purchase supports our small, family-operated business. Plus, they’re shipped straight to your door!